Big Buildings Can Mean Big Economic Disaster
AS BUILDERS BEGIN WORK ON THE FREEDOM TOWER in New York City, to be the world's tallest building, economist Mark Thornton offers a history-based theory of the relation between super-buildings and the economy. Thornton surveyed economic performance worldwide following the completion of each of the world's tallest skyscrapers, and suggests what these events foretell.
Thornton cites example after example to back up his theory. His conclusions may surprise readers, but are based on historical evidence. Thornton reports, "The announcement and groundbreaking for the world's tallest building takes place at the end of a long boom or sustained bubble in the economy." Generally, this is followed by a bear market for stocks, and an economy heading into "recession or worse".
Lest we accept his reasoning without analysis, consider history. The Petronas Towers' completion in Malaysia signaled the Asian Crisis, pushing markets worldwide into a tailspin. The World Trade Center, completed in 1973, and the record-breaking Sears Tower in 1974, led into the dismal 1970's. The Great Depression was heralded by the Wall Street building in 1929, the Chrysler Building in 1930, and the Empire State Building in 1931. The 1913 completion of the 792 foot Woolworth Building foretold only a short downturn in that year, possibly cut short by WWI. As far back as the 1907 Panic, we can draw correlations to Singer's building (finished, '08) and Met Life's building (completed, 09).
One could question the validity of such indicators, just as one might question the "Super Bowl indicator" or other spurious forecasts. But, Thornton makes a good case for why these connections make sense: "Long periods of easy credit create economic booms, particularly in investment, speculation becomes pronounced, and entrepreneurs lose their compass of economic rationality and make big mistakes. The biggest mistakes - record-setting skyscrapers - come toward the end of the long boom and signal the bust."
Even Thornton points out that no such indicator can be foolproof, and we point out that some of these buildings were completed after a downturn, not before. One could say that this building may correlate to the recent dismal economy. But it is wise to consider the possibility that the future may also look bleaker than many in the mainstream media want to admit. Knowing what to expect is core to sound investment strategy. As we've suggested, the present is remarkably difficult to precisely assess. Policies and events represent such a departure from the recent past that normal prediction techniques become largely useless.
The sad thing is that most analysts and forecasters have ignored the uniqueness of today's economy, and continue to base statements and predictions on mismatched methodologies. We're not suggesting that economic law has changed: what has been true remains.. However many analysts assume that today is a carbon copy of the glorious 80's and 90's. In fact, today more closely resembles the 70's, when fear of international war and terrorism dominated, and inflation was of great concern to those who intended to save and invest (and great skyscrapers were being built).
The mainstream blindness is best illustrated by recalling the belief among members of the investment community and economic policy-makers that we were heading toward a period of deflation. Of course, deflation of any size hasn't been seen in the U.S. since the Great Depression, but their indicators led them to conclude that we were heading there. They advocated a more inflationary policy on the part of the government and proposed a Keynesian spending spree.
We would dispute their analysis. We never saw any real deflation, and now, as we've been saying all along, real concerns about inflation are beginning to become realistic. Indeed, it is an election year. History demonstrates that incumbent administrations always follow an inflationary policy in the run-up to the election, printing and spending money to create an exaggerated impression of a good economy. This has been shown to boost re-elections, but also carries with it an inflationary punch that is often seen in the following year(s).
Understanding this simple reality steers us toward intelligent investment decisions. There is clear anticipation of inflation, and rising interest rates, which we are already seeing.
Observing these factors should help us to select investments that will perform well in the coming economy.
We have said that the economy looks strong for the remainder of this year, but as inflation and rising interest rates build next year, a potential for the type of "stagflation" we saw way back under Gerald Ford seems possible.
The market may be beginning to take this potential into account, which explains the downtrend over the past month. Possibly, this fall is the result of terrorism fears that have been drastically overplayed in the media. Terrorism is always a threat, but the idea that we're currently facing a dramatically increased threat is pure election year gamesmanship. Yet, people seem to buy into much of this, and the market follows popular sentiment. Most likely, the recent market drop may simply be a result of earnings disappointments. Most recently, earnings reports have been anything but upbeat, with many companies reporting unexciting results.
With bad earnings already beginning to hit, future economic troubles seem even more ominous. We've been saying all along that the current year should produce good results, but the future was uncertain. We now say that the future is beginning to look less exciting, and may hit sooner than anticipated. This suggests a more defensive strategy.
A defensive strategy is a two-part approach. First, it requires us to get our personal finances in order. This is no time to be carrying unnecessary debt. In the same way, it may be wise to delay those new car loans and leases. Make sure expenses are in tune with income levels, and that ample savings are being put aside as part of the mix. If the future economy is weak, income levels may be constrained, and preparing for the worst is vital. Overlooking this component can make all our good investment choices meaningless.
We mustn't focus only on the downside of the weak economy. Wise investors will look in three different directions for investment success. First, anytime an economy faces weakness, we know to consider stocks that are considered "defensive" - those which will not experience serious downturns from a poor economy. These stocks often pay dividends, which helps to stabilize the share price. This includes food, drug, alcohol, tobacco, and utility firms. Such companies may experience modest downturns in a weak economy, but people still need to eat, still need to use electricity, and still take drugs needed to maintain their well-being. Thus, these stocks generally experience less pressure than other types of firms.
We might choose to delay buying a new car in a weak economy, but we won't really delay buying necessities.
A second type of stocks to consider in an economic downturn may be surprising to some - turnarounds. We've found that times like these may create good opportunities to buy troubled companies. One would think that such "bottomfishing" would be risky in a weak economy, but this is the time when stocks tend to get hit hard when they report weaker than expected results. This creates great buys. Already, we are beginning to see select technology companies selling below book value while maintaining profitability. In a weak economy, such opportunities present themselves, and the upside potential is great. We expect more of these opportunities next year, but some are already beginning to become available. This type of equity can't be expected to provide immediate results. Often they take months or years to turn fully around, so a great deal of patience is required. A different level of investing discipline will be required in these times.
Finally, in an inflationary economy, commodity goods can provide good gains. Thus, stocks such as gold and other mining stocks, oil producers, timber producers, and other natural resource developers may hold promise. While we are inclined to like these stocks generally, many of them have already risen to levels that seem pricey. Overpaying for stocks in this kind of market may prove to be a big mistake, so we're forced to be patient and seek out the few good opportunities in this sector.
Investing in the coming period will not be simple. But opportunities will continue to exist. In such times, selecting stocks carefully and maintaining discipline will be the keys to success.
To send comments to Scott Pearson or to learn more about his Investment Management Services, visit http://www.valueview.net
Scott Pearson is an investment advisor, writer, editor, instructor, and business leader. As President and Chief Investment Officer of Value View Financial Corp., he offers investment management services to a wide variety of clients. His own newsletter, Investor's Value View, is distributed worldwide and provides general money tips and investment advice to readers both internationally, and in the U.S.
More Resources
- Investing:Mutual-Funds Articles from EzineArticles.com
- The Concepts of Risk and Spreading Your Investments
Putting your savings or capital in investments in stocks and shares is subjecting these to a certain amount of risk. Investments fall and rise and can go either way, so you may end up having less cash than your initial outlay. So is there any manner you can safeguard your investment or at best minimize the risk? In a few words yes, by spreading your investments over several different companies and marketplaces.
Read more - Private Equity Funds: The Visionaries That Guide the Corporates of the Future
Today private equity plays a very vital role in international trade and commerce as their investments are not restricted to one particular country or region. These funds have successfully incubated and mentored a host of businesses in India. While the first set of businesses to receive from the software companies, more recently realty and media companies have also sought Private Equity Funds.
Read more - Mutual Fund Share Classes Explained
If you are like most investors you have been exposed to the variety of Mutual Funds and their different classes. Do you understand them? Do you understand how they can affect your returns? Read more to learn about one of the Fund industry's big mysteries. Most Mutual Funds offer multiple classes of shares. They all invest in the same underlying fund but the expenses and commissions paid, referred to as "load", are varying and can serious affect the returns you realize. Most Mutual Funds offer three share classes which are typically referred to as A, B, and C share classes, and loads and fees vary per share class.
Read more - Managing Risk Through Mutual Funds
Does the current stock market volatility make you want to stick your head in the sand and forget about it? Don't despair! If you read last month's article "Risk is a Four Letter Word", then you know that investing always carries some form of risk; whether market risk, company/industry risk, currency/country risk, reinvestment risk, interest rate risk, liquidity risk or inflation risk. While you can't eliminate risk entirely, there is a way to minimize these risks so that you can sleep well at night. Mutual funds are one such way that the small investor can participate in various investment vehicles while reducing risk.
Read more - A Basic Introduction to Hedge Funds
What is a hedge fund? Learn the basics of hedge funds including their investment strategies and structure.
Read more - What to Look for When Selecting a Mutual Fund
Most active mutual fund managers underperform the market. Following the tips given in the article will improve chances of better investment performance.
Read more - Perks in Investing in Mutual Funds
Whether your goal is a comfortable retirement, education, travel, a new home or simply to accumulate money, mutual funds can help you achieve your investment objectives. A mutual fund is simply an investment that allows people with similar financial goals to pool their resources. Professional fund managers invest that money in various securities that meet the objectives of the fund. Investing your money in Mutual funds offer many distinct advantages.
Read more - The Many Benefits Of Mutual Funds Explained
The idea of creating mutual funds often catches the interest of those who desire to increase their income. These people believe that considering such investments could soon lead them to the kind of life that they want or to secure future during their old age. While these could be one of the benefits of mutual funds, there are certain risks that you need to manage well in the process.
Read more - More About Superannuations
Superannuation is a form of self managed super fund and is a very smart way to invest money and to provide for older age. The idea behind a superannuation is to invest a pot of money in order to gain interest, normally with the intention of saving for retirement. Anyone can submit to a superannuation be they employers, employees or self employed, and here they will submit the money in a series of payments over an agreed timescale in much the same way that you might submit money to a pension scheme in monthly or annual payments.
Read more - Some (Better) Ways to Invest Your Money
Investing your money is something that everyone should do and that is highly important if you want to make the most of your existing assets. By investing your money you will first and foremost find that you are able to grow your initial pot into a larger sum, and this is of course going to be very beneficial. At the same time though, you will also find that by investing your money you are keeping it away from yourself and this means that you won't fritter it away on day to day expenses.
Read more - Long - Term Investments For Retirement Planning
To build and maintain a successful retirement portfolio, you have to find mutual funds that will best help you achieve your objectives. In the early 90's, I searched for mutual funds that had to have: 1) average or low risk, 2) above average performance, and 3) distribution of large dividends...
Read more - The Different Types Of Mutual Funds You Need To Know
There are many different types of mutual funds for investors to choose from. No matter the type of investor that you are, you should be in position to know which are the best mutual funds for your investment needs.
Read more - Fog Over China
When we came into this year, we expected the Chinese stock market to offer the next big opportunity for gains now that the U.S. market was rallying. We have been following China with that in mind. We even took the beating of the Chinese market last year as creating an opportunity this year.
Read more - Is It Just the Weather - Fundamental Forces
The title we give to this article is our way of asking whether there are fundamental forces that are driving the rally or is the market just in a temporary phase that will shortly give way to another phase? A random walk, if you will. Obviously, we think there is more going on than just an extended, but temporary, mood shift by investors.
Read more - Smart Investments to Make For Retirement
Let's face it, last year's investment markets were volatile and full of uncertainties for the average investor, like myself. In trying to even the 'playing field', especially for a retirement portfolio, it is imperative to make investments that has a proven long-term positive performance record (number of years of gains far exceed number of years of losses). This goal should be the foundation of your type of retirement investment.
Read more
